This Amish romance anthology pairs a sweet story of connection with a suspenseful cold case mystery.

The Amish Midwife by Patricia Davids

Amish midwife Anne Stoltzfus is shocked at neighbor Joseph Lapp’s request. Now responsible for his baby niece, Joseph is in over his head and needs a nanny fast. Soon they’re bonding over baby Leah, and when Joseph makes an offer of marriage, Anne realizes that taking a chance could mean love—and family—are waiting just across the fence.

Plain Pursuit by Alison Stone

When her brother is killed in a small Amish town, Anna Quinn finds she’s an unwelcome outsider. FBI agent Eli Miller left his Amish community long ago, but he’s discovering a cold case from his past has mysterious connections to Anna’s loss. Desperate to uncover the truth, Anna and Eli are faced with stony silence and secrets that someone wants to keep buried.