Living with a secret fetish of trans-girls is something Caleb keeps to himself. His fascination is not something the people in his religious community would understand nor would his girlfriend. With an unexpected new girl transferring into his high school, Caleb is now one of the very few people who knows Elizabeth's secret that she has tucked between her legs. Caleb tries blackmail and finds that he is not good at it and blows his chance to experience sex with a transexual.

Caleb now finds himself with a second chance as he is now in college with Elizabeth who happens to be in the same class with him. With a different tactic, Caleb soon enjoys the splendor having having sex with the girl he once blackmailed. As things progress, so does romance and having to deal with the emotions have dating a trans girl.